Jill I did look for the 1864 one & not buried at St Nicholas.
Now we know why thanks to Kiterunner
I did find this one buried at St Nicholas.
Joseph Kershaw Died in Newchurch Age 66 on the 29th Dec 1870
Buried 2nd Jan 1871
Also his wife Betty who died age 65 10th April 1870
Also in the same grave are John Kershaw died age 74 15th June 1847
Also his wife Grace Kershaw died age 80 12th Nov 1852.
I do have a few more people but will PM the rest to you.
Could be the Joseph Kershaw. Jay found 1871 Death same one as
the one I found.